Given the AI actor's fleeting cameo in a short skit, the uproar against digital creation Tilly Norwood has been rapid and overwhelming. Viewers, Hollywood, and critics have joined in condemnation, visibly disgusted.
Stars were particularly quick to condemn a concept that is – plainly – depressing, dystopian, and legally suspect should it use unauthorized likenesses. It is also plain shonky: a critic has pointed out on Tilly’s unconvincing smile, but there are noticeable issues that mean the technology isn't mature.
Still, a major US union responded against the demonstration screened at a conference by stating it believed creativity was, “and ought to stay human-centred. It stands against the replacement of real actors by digital substitutes”.
Leading performers urged representation companies not to sign the likes of Tilly to their books. “Deeply misguided and totally disturbed,” commented. “Not the direction. Not the energy.” Her counterpart expressed in an interview: “Good Lord, we’re screwed. It's deeply alarming … Don't erase genuine interaction.”
‘It’s too late to be scared’: readers on the controversial rise of AI ‘actors’
To which one can only reply: I agree! And also: really? Because such cheerleading for naturalism can feel rather hypocritical. Performers claim they are committed to human connection and sincere portrayal. They likely think so. Yet both cinema and the choices they pursue tell a different story.
This award season, at least several actresses, all top-tier, none older than early 40s, appear to have had procedures done on their face that causes what many of us might consider their key appeal altered, or at least changed, permanently.
Cheeks have been smoothed, features refined and mouths enhanced. Appearances have become uniform, homogenised, blandified – all done surgically!
They haven't acknowledged changes, and these actions are of course private matters. Except that their profession is meant to depict relatable characters, while benefiting from the affection and association audiences have built up over a number of years in which they looked … unique.
Not long ago I watched an intense new drama starring an affected performer and was totally thrown by the sudden differences to her face: understated, yet still substantial enough to be unsettling.
In the past, that face was an element of her appeal that meant viewers were willing to watch her perform in lesser roles – and often did. Instead, I spent the entire film feeling distanced, regretful and a bit scared: sensations that disrupt believability.
Presumably the pressures on female actors to maintain youthfulness are considerable enough to mean numerous pursue enhancements – for which, it's understandable. Yet undergoing procedures to try to defy nature does make assertions of valuing realism tough to accept.
It’s not just the women, of course: the effect is just more apparent. At times the entire entertainment climate feels like an arena of narcissism. We are living in an era of actor-focused films, in which many of this year's notable films serve to feed the egos of their leads rather than serve viewers.
The Tilly Norwood phenomenon: assessing the AI threat
A new release stars a major celebrity as a character resembling him, and is filled with insights into the struggles and triumphs of celebrity life. Further releases which may strike the deepest chord with those who are in the spotlight include a comedy special, a rock star story, a sports drama and a heartfelt movie – such films further fruits of Hollywood’s endless hunger for entertainment biopics.
Elsewhere we have a performance-heavy film the definition of an actors’ movie, in which well-known performers are allowed every opportunity to overact while looking extremely attractive, as well as a legendary actor's authored comeback, and a top star's endearingly messy parent in a chaotic adventure.
Several examples are actually well-made. A couple are excellent. But if actors want to not alienate audiences, to shed light on reality as most people experience it, they might consider diversifying the topics of their scripts. And they definitely need to stop cosmetically transforming into – well, into Tilly Norwood.